Pengy the Pennbrook Penguin is the mascot of the Pennbrook Penguins, the football team. When the Penguins were preparing for a big game against the Amish, Eric unveiled the mascot as an Amish spy who had tried to steal their playbook. The job open, Cory applied. Cory, however, proved to be a terrible penguin when he fell into the band and knocked over the tubas.
Topanga, unaware a replacement for Cory had been located, approached the mascot during a celebration and asked them to hold her. As "Pengy"'s hand moved to her butt, she noticed Cory standing some distance away. Angered, she punched out the mascot and approached Cory.